1916: Sterling 13 Geneseo 7
1917: Sterling 27 Geneseo 7
1917: Sterling 25 Geneseo 0
1922: Sterling 27 Geneseo 0
1942: Geneseo 6 Sterling 0
1944: Sterling 26 Geneseo 13
1945: Geneseo 26 Sterling 6
1947: Sterling 14 Geneseo 12
1950: Sterling 31 Geneseo 6
1951: Sterling 34 Geneseo 12
1953: Sterling 35 Geneseo 20
1954: Sterling 44 Geneseo 0
1955: Sterling 64 Geneseo 7
1956: Geneseo 19 Sterling 12
1981: Sterling 14 Geneseo 7
1982: Sterling 16 Geneseo 12
1983: Sterling 43 Geneseo 0
1984: Sterling 10 Geneseo 7
1985: Geneseo 7 Sterling 0
1986: Geneseo 30 Sterling 6
1987: Geneseo 12 Sterling 6
1988: Sterling 27 Geneseo 24
1989: Geneseo 40 Sterling 8
1990: Geneseo 40 Sterling 6
1991: Sterling 14 Geneseo 7
1992: Geneseo 14 Sterling 7
1993: Geneseo 53 Sterling 16
1994: Sterling 27 Geneseo 6
1994: Sterling 13 Geneseo 12
(4A 2nd Round)
1995: Sterling 35 Geneseo 6
1996: Geneseo 27 Sterling 24
1997: Geneseo 31 Sterling 24
1998: Geneseo 24 Sterling 12
1999: Geneseo 10 Sterling 7
2000: Geneseo 37 Sterling 12
2001: Geneseo 55 Sterling 0
2002: Geneseo 28 Sterling 14
2003: Geneseo 30 Sterling 12
2004: Geneseo 21 Sterling 0
2005: Sterling 28 Geneseo 7
2006: Geneseo 13 Sterling 10
2007: Sterling 14 Geneseo 3
2008: Sterling 31 Geneseo 14
2009: Geneseo 17 Sterling 7
2010: Sterling 14 Geneseo 7
2011: Sterling 35 Geneseo 21
2012: Sterling 24 Geneseo 20
2013: Geneseo 38 Sterling 19
2014: Geneseo 30 Sterling 20
2015: Sterling 17 Geneseo 14
2016: Sterling 49 Geneseo 7
2017: Sterling 45 Geneseo 8
2018: Sterling 43 Geneseo 7
2019: Sterling 27 Geneseo 7
2020: Sterling 41 Geneseo 0
2021: Sterling 31 Geneseo 0
2022: Sterling 40 Geneseo 0
2023: Sterling 13 Geneseo 3
2024: Sterling 13 Geneseo 6
